You know the feeling. You’ve put in the miles, the hills, the interval training. Now it’s race day and you’re having a good one. You feel balanced, light, and fast. You press the pace one more click and leave another pack of runners behind.

Then it happens. Your foot comes down on a rock and rolls painfully inward. You hear a sickening “pop,” you go down, and the runners you just passed thunder past you. Nauseating pain overwhelms your interest in the torn skin on your hands and stays with you throughout the long limp back to town.

Here in Los Gatos we’re fortunate to have miles of unpaved recreational trails and utility roads, such as the Los Gatos Creek Trail, the Flume Trail, the Jones Trail, and the Limekiln Trail, offering a variety of terrain through our open space preserves. The race described above could well be our own late-summer annual event, the Dammit Run. If you suffer an ankle sprain while running in competition or in training, here’s what you need to know to get back on the trail and back up to speed.

A Few Definitions
A ligament is a band of fibrous tissue in a joint connecting bone to bone. Each joint has several ligaments. Ligaments are distinct from tendons, which connect muscle to bone. Ligaments support and strengthen joints and make joints stable by limiting joint motion from movements in unwanted directions.

A sprain occurs when a ligament is stretched beyond its normal limits. Sprains are classified according to degrees of severity. A Grade I sprain involves damaging a ligament but not compromising its function of restraining unwanted motion. In a Grade II sprain, the ligament is partially torn and allows some unwanted motion. In a Grade III sprain, the ligament is completely torn and cannot stop unwanted motion, and joint stability and function are lost. Grade III sprains cause diffuse swelling and bruising around the affected joint.

A sprain is more than a simple mechanical injury. Sprains affect proprioception, the neural feedback mechanism that enables us to know the angles of our joints, and the positions of our limbs and extremities, without looking. Good proprioception is what enables us to run in the dark without thinking about where to put our feet, or land a jump shot when focusing on the hoop.

First Aid for Sprains
First Aid for sprains can be remembered by the acronym  “RICE,” (Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation). For Grade I sprains, First Aid treatment alone is often adequate. Grade II and III sprains require rapid administration of First Aid, plus medical evaluation and treatment including some external support, such as a McDavid ankle brace , to protect the ligament while healing. Complete recovery from a Grade II or Grade III sprain is unlikely to occur without medical attention.

Recovery from Sprain
Recovery from a sprain involves promoting the healing of the ligament, elimination of swelling and bruising, increasing strength, and restoring proprioception. At Physical Therapy of Los Gatos the goal of treatment is returning the individual to their pre-injury level of activities and sports, without elevated risk of re-injury. If our runner returns to training on the Los Gatos Creek Trail without fully restored proprioception, he or she will find intense concentration is needed on the exact placement of each foot-fall to prevent the injured ankle from rolling inward again. Longer term, residual changes in joint forces and mechanics, due to incomplete recovery, can accelerate degenerative changes and conditions, such as arthritis.

Restoring Proprioception
Proprioception is based on neural feedback loops that carry and compare information from the eyes and middle ear, and from the stretch receptors of muscles and connective tissues. Following a sprain injury, proprioception is restored by thoroughly rehabilitating neuromuscular control over the affected joint with facilitory techniques such as compression, vibration, and biofeedback. This must be accomplished in a way that promotes, rather than impairs, healing of the injured ligament, and trains the surrounding muscles to assist the injured ligament in supporting the joint while it heals.

Elements of Therapy for Sprain
Therapy begins with a thorough evaluation of the sprain injury. If a Grade III sprain is suspected, the injury should be evaluated by an orthopedic specialist, who will order and evaluate X-ray or MRI images to detect any damage to the underlying bone structure of the affected joint and to obtain a clear picture of soft tissue injuries. Evaluation of a sprain performed by a physical therapist or a physician will also include stress tests to measure the extent of abnormal joint motion caused by the injury, and the progressive tightening of the joint as the injured ligament heals, as compared to the stress-bearing characteristics of the opposite joint and normative values.

In addition to specific, individualized strengthening exercises aimed at re-establishing neuromuscular control and joint strength, physical therapy for sprain should also include evaluation and training of muscles affecting the entire limb of the injured joint. For instance, when ankle pain, weakness, or injury compromise proprioceptive cues, the hips and low back muscles will compensate by altering the injured individuals’ walking and running patterns. Because the goal of therapy is complete recovery, including normal or improved function, specific, progressive exercises are prescribed over the course of rehabilitation to restore motion, strength, and control throughout the entire limb.

If you suspect you have a joint injury involving ligament sprain, please contact us for expert advice by calling (408) 358-6505. For additional information about ankle sprain, see the related article “Foot and Ankle Injuries of Ballet Dancers.”

At the September 2005 Western Occupational Health Conference, Physical Therapy of Los Gatos principal Rob Naber delivered presentations on anterior knee pain and lumbar active range of motion. At the same conference, Rob also gave a somewhat more technical presentation for physicians on the topic of lumbar spine stability. This web site article was adapted from his presentation notes and materials.

Lumbar spine stability is an important concept in orthopedic medicine because its absence is often identified as the cause of lower back pain. When the lumbar spine is insufficiently stable, the motion between the joints of the lower back is exaggerated and abnormal. A patient with lumbar spine instability will experience lower back pain when the joints of the lumbar spine “wobble” in use rather than transferring forces with the smooth, synchronous movements of a healthy spine.

If lumbar spine instability is identified as the cause in a case of lower back pain, lumbar spine stabilization must be the cure. Too often this simplistic view of the relationship between lumbar spine stability and lower back pain is used as the basis for handing out “core strengthening” exercise instructions as a treatment for lower back pain. Few cases of lower back pain caused by lumbar spine instability are relieved by pre-printed handouts of abdominal and paraspinal, or “core,” strengthening exercises.

While we encourage our patients toward any healthy form of exercise, including those forms that address core strength, we are critical of physical therapists and other health care providers who prescribe pre-printed, generic strengthening exercises to patients suffering from lower back pain. In most cases, these exercises will fail to provide any relief. And unfortunately, the most motivated patients receiving these instructions will succeed in strengthening their abdominal and paraspinal muscles. Greater strength will cause untreated lumbar spine joint wobbling to occur with greater force and velocity, and the patient will feel much worse.

In the maintenance of healthy lumbar spine stability, muscle endurance is more important than muscle strength. Furthermore, muscle endurance, the condition of ligaments, and motor control of the structures supporting the spine must be in balance if lumbar spine stability is to be achieved. Generic muscle strengthening regimes that disregard initial measures of paraspinal and abdominal wall muscle endurance, and do not aim to restore correct, specific, balanced, and sustainable force vector ratios around the lumbar spine will fail to produce measurable improvements and will likely increase the patient’s pain and disability.

At Physical Therapy of Los Gatos, our physical therapists are trained to evaluate lumbar spine instability using effective methods and clinical precision. Measurements taken during the evaluation phase of therapy and at key intervals over the course of treatment include timed isometric holding exercises in right and left “side plank” positions, a sixty degree sit-up position, and the Biering-Sorensen position (pictured). The results of these tests are compared with normative time values determined in research studies and are used to design individualized treatment protocols to restore correct force vector ratios around the lumbar spine. These individualized treatment protocols produce complete and rapid recoveries from lower back pain caused by lumbar instability.

Lumbar Spine Stabilization presentation by Rob Naber to the 2005 Western Occupational Health Conference (765 KB .pdf

Conference Program Abstract (76 KB .pdf download)

An unintended consequence of the increase in sports participation by girls and young women over the past thirty years has been an extraordinary rise in the incidence of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries in young female athletes. At the college level, one in ten young female athletes participating in sports such as soccer, volleyball, and basketball will suffer an ACL tear injury. These girls are typically unable to practice or compete for one or more seasons and face potential loss of scholarship funding and significant psychological trauma. A widely cited 1985 study found that at the high school level, the knee injury rate among female athletes is one per 100 participants, and noted the need for preventative measures.

In 1983, sports medicine researchers determined that four-fifths of ACL injuries are non-contact injuries, that is, they are caused by the athlete’s own motions rather than collisions with other players. To the researchers, this finding meant that the high incidence of ACL tear injuries in young female athletes might be greatly reduced if those motions could be identified and avoided.

The ACL is one of four major ligaments that connect the upper and lower leg at the knee. The ACL provides joint stability and supports cutting and pivoting motions. Oftentimes, the ACL will tear with a “pop” that can be heard by spectators and other players. Pain and immediate swelling follow. ACL tears require surgical reconstruction using tendon grafts from other areas of the knee or from cadavers, followed by a long period of rehabilitation.

The frequency and seriousness of ACL tears in young female athletes has led to research studies aimed at understanding the problem. These studies are now yielding valuable data. Three major hypotheses to account for the higher number of ACL tears in female athletes versus male athletes have been examined: hormonal differences causing laxity of the female athlete’s ACL, a smaller and more narrow space within the knee for the female athlete’s ACL, and sex-based differences in lower extremity strength and coordination. The last of these three hypotheses is receiving the most scientific support from study data.

Certain aspects of lower extremity strength and coordination can be captured and measured by videotaping athletes while they perform athletic movements in the research lab. While video recordings do not capture complex three-dimensional movements and the rotational stresses that these movements place upon the knees, the recordings do enable researchers to make close measurements of joint and limb positions in a single plane. These measurements were found to have predictive value.

In one well-designed study of 205 young female athletes, researchers found that athletes with a specific way of posturing their lower extremities, known as “valgus” (or “knock-kneed”) alignment, during certain athletic movements were more likely to suffer ACL injury than athletes with more “neutral” or straighter lower extremity alignment. This valgus alignment can be seen by analyzing the angles formed between the ankles, knees, and hips when the athlete lands from a jump off a small box and when she jumps vertically from a crouched position. A separate study that included videographic analysis of 325 young female athletes showed that a six-week neuromuscular training program corrected the lower limb valgus alignment associated with injury during jump landing and takeoff.

It is already well-known to physical therapists that muscular strength stabilizes the knee by helping to maintain the correct relative positions of knee structures during sports movements and by allowing muscles in the legs to absorb forces that would otherwise subject the joint to potential injury. But physical therapists treating young female athletes must now consider the implications of the new studies. Physical therapists familiar with these studies infer that rehabilitation from ACL injury should, in addition to conventional strength training treatment methods, include specific neuromuscular training aimed at improving the athlete’s ability to avoid valgus alignment of the lower extremities during high-risk sports.

It is no longer acceptable to reconstruct the ACL but leave neuromuscular control deficient.

The jump strength training program at Physical Therapy of Los Gatos is an element of rehabilitation from surgical reconstruction of the ACL as well as a standalone performance improvement module. The program includes jump analysis, strength conditioning, and neuromuscular training designed to improve power and acceleration. The neuromuscular training methods employed include visual, auditory and proprioceptive cues to train athletes to use muscular strength to absorb jump impacts in a controlled fashion, and, if necessary, to correct jumping, landing, and pivoting techniques in order to avoid forces associated with injury. For additional information about prevention of ACL injury, rehabilitation from surgical ACL repair, and jump strength performance training for athletes, please call Physical Therapy of Los Gatos at (408) 358-6505.